Cognitive Security · Paper · 2022

From Users to (Sense)Makers: On the Pivotal Role of Stigmergic Social Annotation in the Quest for Collective Sensemaking

Ronen Tamari, Daniel Friedman, William Fischer, Lauren Hebert, Dafna Shahaf

Hypertext '22

Download PDF Publication source Paper folder on GitHub Read extracted text

Overview

We argue that centralized platforms are a main source of epistemic pollution online, and propose Open Source Attention—a socio-technical framework for freeing human attention from platform control through a decentralized ecosystem for creating, storing, and querying stigmergic markers: the digital traces of human attention. We frame social annotation as a collective sensemaking tool that can restore epistemic health to online environments.

stigmergic annotationopen source attentioncollective sensemakingepistemic pollutiondecentralized platformssocial annotationdigital attention

Overview source: Curated paper metadata.

Methods and contributions

Read the source for the full argument, qualifications, and evidence.

Findings and contributions

  • The authors argue that centralized platforms are a main source of epistemic pollution and that healthier environments require redesigning how attention is collectively governed.
  • They propose Open Source Attention, a framework for a decentralized ecosystem for creating, storing and querying stigmergic markers as digital traces of attention.
  • OSA aims to 'free' stigmergic markers starting from basic hypertext primitives: likes, bi-directional links, span highlighting, tags/bookmarks, and textual annotation.
  • The authors suggest existing personal knowledge management tools could be bootstrapped toward collective knowledge management via interoperable protocols and storage for stigmergic primitives.

Methods

  • Stigmergic-cognition lens: sematectonic stigmergy vs stigmergic markers — Frames online sensemaking using the distinction between content-altering sematectonic stigmergy and signalling stigmergic markers such as likes, annotations and links.
  • Three-element architecture for a maker-centered ecology — Specifies the proposed ecosystem as annotation tools, self-sovereign storage, and content discovery services, contrasted with a platform-centric loop (Fig. 1).
  • Comparison with the Solid ecosystem and dokieli annotation client — Positions the proposal against Solid and dokieli as the closest existing decentralization efforts and notes their limitations.

Summary sources: Paper metadata and evidence · Extracted source text.

Document downloads

PDFs are hosted here; supporting sources may use pinned archives.

Citation

Citation metadata follows the unified bibliography.

Tamari, Ronen; Friedman, Daniel; Fischer, William; Hebert, Lauren; Shahaf, Dafna. 2022. From Users to (Sense)Makers: On the Pivotal Role of Stigmergic Social Annotation in the Quest for Collective Sensemaking. Hypertext '22. DOI: 10.48550/arXiv.2205.06345. URL: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2205.06345.
Download bibliography Add to reading list Explore connections

Catalog details and resources

Catalog row68
Citation keyFriedman2022FromUsersSenseMakers068
Platform availability

Related works

Ranked by recorded methods, topics, contributors and associated software, with contributor roles and domain-only matches labelled. Metadata overlap is not a citation or a scientific equivalence.

View all Cognitive Security works, software & media →