---
# docxology:generated-document SKILL.md; ownership=explicit-manifest
name: "Personal Red Lines for Development"
description: "A versioned, evidence-gated personal security boundary and explicit No document for dual-use development work. It requires a complete, reviewable action intake before returning compliance, distinguishes outside-scope work from compliance, and records..."
tags: ["red-lines", "ai-governance", "dual-use", "cognitive-security", "hash-based-canary", "precommitment", "open-science", "personal-governance", "global-political-thought", "research-ethics"]
domain: "Cognitive Security"
citation: "Daniel Ari Friedman (2026). *Personal Red Lines for Development*. Zenodo."
doi: "10.5281/zenodo.24069255"
---

# Personal Red Lines for Development

**Daniel Ari Friedman** (2026) · Cognitive Security

## Context

This work addresses topics in **Cognitive Security**: red lines, AI governance, dual-use, cognitive security.

## Methods

Primary methods and techniques applied in this work:

- **Versioned machine-readable registry of seven first-person refusals** — The author's seven red lines are recorded as a versioned registry that a proposed engagement is checked against via a strict intake gate.
- **Nine-dimension evidence-gated ActionContext intake** — Each intake must carry a VERIFIED evidence record for nine dimensions (purpose, end use, affected parties, provenance, legal basis, etc.) before policy matching.
- **Adaptation of Turner's government AI red-line framework** — Turner's organization-to-government red line and oversight framework serves as mechanism source, adapted to one practitioner without importing its authority.
- **Deterministic registry hashing and canary attestation** — Durability is implemented as hashing of canonical registry content and a canary that detects drift only against a prior copy held outside the writer's control.
- **Five-fixture outcome-coverage battery through the real evaluator** — A harness runs five ProposedAction fixtures, one per classification, through evaluate_action against the live registry at a fixed review date.

## Key Findings

Core contributions and results:

- Every intake is classified into one of five categories; missing, self-asserted, unverified, stale or contradicted context cannot produce COMPLIANT.
- Degrading any one of the nine intake dimensions withdrew a compliant result in all 45 executed evaluations; an ALL-mode exemption stayed unreachable by a single token across 58 more.
- All five classifications were reached by the fixture battery, but the fixtures are not evidence that any real engagement was reviewed, safe or lawful.
- The author states decisive limitations: local evidence is not independent truth verification, lexical matching is not semantic understanding, and code is not enforcement.
- The evaluator's visible boundary is a 34-word scope vocabulary, so OUTSIDE_SCOPE is a bounded registry statement rather than a safety claim.

Methods and findings are summarized from the full text; each item is backed by a verbatim quote recorded in `metadata.json` (`evidence`, `key_findings_evidence`).

## Related Works

See [BIBLIOGRAPHY.md](../../pages/BIBLIOGRAPHY.md) for related publications.

## Validation

Verification points for this work:

- Canonical DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24069255
- PDF SHA-256: See zenodo_record
- Pairing confidence: unknown
- Last checked: 2026-08-02T15:12:41Z

## Prerequisites

- Familiarity with red lines, AI governance, dual-use
- Background in Cognitive Security fundamentals
- Access to source repository: N/A

## Instructions

When working with this paper:

1. Reference the DOI for citation: `10.5281/zenodo.24069255`
2. Apply methods listed in the Methods section for related analysis.
3. Validate findings against the original PDF and metadata.
