---
# docxology:generated-document SKILL.md; ownership=explicit-manifest
name: "The Properties, Processes, and Perspectives Inter-Framework (P3IF): Multiplexing interdisciplinary requirements frameworks to manage information risk and foster cognitive security"
description: "Requirements engineering frameworks have historically been developed in the context of cybersecurity and have tended to focus almost exclusively on the technical and operational aspects of data security. Now, however, frameworks are being stretched t..."
tags: ["p3if", "information-risk", "cognitive-security", "interdisciplinary-frameworks", "requirements-management", "dhs", "health-security"]
domain: "Cognitive Security"
citation: "Thomas M. Wilkinson, RJ Cordes, Scott David, Daniel Ari Friedman (2023). *The Properties, Processes, and Perspectives Inter-Framework (P3IF): Multiplexing interdisciplinary requirements frameworks to manage information risk and foster cognitive security*. Zenodo."
doi: "10.5281/zenodo.10034511"
---

# The Properties, Processes, and Perspectives Inter-Framework (P3IF): Multiplexing interdisciplinary requirements frameworks to manage information risk and foster cognitive security

**Thomas M. Wilkinson, RJ Cordes, Scott David, Daniel Ari Friedman** (2023) · Cognitive Security

## Context

This work addresses topics in **Cognitive Security**: P3IF, information risk, cognitive security, interdisciplinary frameworks.

## Methods

Primary methods and techniques applied in this work:

- **Snowball citation-tracking review of combinatorial requirements frameworks** — Starting from well-known frameworks (CIA triad, McCumber Cube, DoDAF), manual citation tracking identified antecedent and derived frameworks; 41 were included as of August 2023.
- **Coda.io knowledge base and UI for framework collection** — Built a front-end UI and knowledge management system on the low-code Coda.io platform to store bibliographic, visual and textual aspects of each framework.
- **Phylo-memetic lineage trees of framework clades** — Parent/child relationships from citation histories and direct references were arranged into phylogenetic-type trees grouping frameworks into seven context clades.
- **Sorting framework dimensions into Properties, Processes, Perspectives** — Dimensions and attributes of the collected frameworks were categorized into three general categories that form the basis of the proposed P3IF.

## Key Findings

Core contributions and results:

- All dimensions and attributes of the examined frameworks fit into one of three emergent categories: Properties, Processes, or Perspectives.
- Derivative frameworks tend to be released as standalone replacements and are generally not backwards compatible.
- The more expansive multi-factor frameworks were the most difficult to document due to inconsistent documentation, variable proliferation and visualization limits.
- The paper proposes P3IF, a modular abstraction layer between existing frameworks that extends rather than replaces them.
- The authors state the analysis is not an exhaustive or systematic meta-analysis but an initial snapshot of a sample of frameworks.

Methods and findings are summarized from the full text; each item is backed by a verbatim quote recorded in `metadata.json` (`evidence`, `key_findings_evidence`).

## Related Works

- [2020_EmergentTeams](../2020_EmergentTeams/)
- [2020_FacilitatorsCatechism](../2020_FacilitatorsCatechism/)
- [2020_GreatPreset](../2020_GreatPreset/)

## Validation

Verification points for this work:

- Canonical DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.10034511
- PDF SHA-256: See zenodo_record
- Pairing confidence: unknown
- Last checked: 2026-06-30T23:25:20Z

## Prerequisites

- Familiarity with P3IF, information risk, cognitive security
- Background in Cognitive Security fundamentals
- Access to source repository: N/A

## Instructions

When working with this paper:

1. Reference the DOI for citation: `10.5281/zenodo.10034511`
2. Apply methods listed in the Methods section for related analysis.
3. Validate findings against the original PDF and metadata.
